Pages

Friday, March 20, 2009

Differences between American and Hispanic culture, v1.4b

I'm sure I say this plenty, but the gap between what is seen in America versus what I've grown up with is vastly different in certain respects. I've already talked about how I find Americans have trouble with more intimate contact, which still upsets me. One of the reasons I love Hispanic culture is because the walls are torn down when it comes to a sense of intimacy in a verbal and physical sense, even between strangers.

Corey reminded me of this the other day when she was reading an e-mail from my mother over my shoulder. It was addressed to my brother and me, and started out with, "Queridos amores," directly translated - Dear loves - yet it has more sentiment than even those two words in English. Our e-mails usually end the same way, even when I write to my parents. This time, my mom concluded with "Los amo mis adorados hijos, Diosito me los cuide y me los bendiga siempre," or, "I love you my beloved sons, may God protect you and bless you always."

In addition to cutesy, heartfelt correspondence, my family, and most Hispanic people I know, will always say "good morning" to each other in the morning, up until noon, and when people bid each other farewell in the evening, will always say "good night." I find that's not always true in my interactions with people in daily life. I sometimes get strange looks when saying "good morning" to my co-workers, other people in the department, or even the bus drivers. My saluation is also not reciprocated with a "good morning" back, but a "hi" or "hey" or something like that. Since when was it wrong to say "good morning" to a fellow peer? Does it sound too formal? Regardless, it's slightly irritating, but I guess it's so commonplace when I speak Spanish that I feel like it should carry over. I mean, even when I walk into a bodega (Hispanic convenience store) or restaurant, I'm greeted with either "Buenas," or "good day," or something even cuter, such as, "Hola mi hijo" (Hi my son), or "Que tal, corazon?"(How's it going, love?) [literally, heart, not love]. It just makes any sort of interaction, regardless of how well you know the person, that much more pleasant and enjoyable.

Corey thought it was so cute how communications between my family and me start like that, whereas I didn't think much of it. But after some thinking, I realized that a lot of people I know are threatened by showing such displays of emotion and intimacy among each other for fear of having others think negatively of them or something - of being called weak, gay, or something else perhaps. I know I'm probably overgeneralizing, but I find it's true more often than not. I feel like Americans should learn from this, but maybe that's just my bias talking. I guess the gap is wider than I sometime think or remember. Maybe I'll start a social experiment and start hugging more often, or even kissing my friends on the cheek after a firm hug to see what happens.

4 comments:

  1. Claro que si. Me parece que muchas de las culturas hispanicas y europeas tienen mas emocion que las de los EEUU. :p

    Not sure if that made any sense, my Spanish is still quite rusty. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, to be fair, it's not always an attitude based in fear of negative judgment. I do know what you're talking about, but I don't think that applies in every case. I believe American culture is a lot more centered around individuality and personal space than many other cultures. America is huge, so it's a cultural attitude that makes sense, whereas it wouldn't work in a much smaller country. Physical and emotional demonstrations of affection have both a good and bad side: they can be uplifting as well as being smothering or invasive. I understand and sympathize with the discomfort more than you do because it's the culture I've been raised in. So I don't really think either cultural attitude is "right," they just take different extremes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For what it's worth, I say "good morning" to people at work, and get the same in response - maybe Ithaca's just too laid back?

    I partially agree with s. You'll probably always feel that the ways of expressing affection in the culture you grew up with are the warmest. I've read that men in some Islamic countries show friendship by holding hands in public. I guess it just shows you how different cultures can be, but I hate to use a word "extreme" since "normal" is completely relative.

    I'd also hesitate to say American culture is centered around individuality. Personal space and privacy sure, but Americans seem pretty bipolar about individuality.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When I say "individuality" I mean it in the sense of "what's best for the individual" vs. "what's best for the group."

    ReplyDelete